Award Winner
In Majorca, the vineyards have been stripped naked. No bodies work in those fields; no falcons circle the grounds. Occasionally, a car rattles along the nearby highway, but mostly, it is quiet. Across the way, on the crest of a hill, stands a lonely Finca composed of smooth stone and green shutters. Branches, twisted, climb along its exterior, spraying blood-orange and magenta blooms.
A bus pulls up along the narrow driveway, releasing a current of people. These people are writers, and they are all women. Most have traveled from the United Kingdom, but some have come as far as Canada and the United States of America. They are here for a writing retreat. Most are unsure what to expect. As they enter and travel the bleak stairwell to unburden themselves of their luggage, there is an almost imperceptible breath of relief at the sight of chilled prosecco in the foyer whose contents will soon soften their misgivings.
A man in his fifties greets each of them, sometimes offering to carry their bags, though he is quick to clarify that he is “not a busboy.” This man is also a writer; his name is P. and he has won awards and is known by some. In his photos online, he stands straight with combed hair and steely eyes, handsome in a fitted suit. His photo does not match his person. On this night, his shirt clings to his belly and his eyes regard the world behind a pair of spectacles.
P. will be lecturer, advisor, and mentor this week. He will be the center of it all, a role that comes naturally to him.
The women are tired. Many want to take a nap, but they don’t want to be rude on their first day, so they listen to the organizers—Maria and Lacy—rattle off the week’s itinerary, which includes workshops and nightly salons where they may choose to read their work.
On the first night, everyone sits at a communal table to eat their sausages and mashed potatoes. This will be the heartiest meal of the week, and some of them will later quietly complain that the food is scant and leaves much to be desired. One woman, Cate, will generously offer her companions some of the Snickers bars she’s stashed away in her suitcase; everyone will decline out of politeness, even as their stomachs rumble.
After dinner, the women allow themselves to be corralled into a room by P. where he will play them a recording of one of his short stories, read by a BAFTA-nominated actress. He mentions that now that he is well-known, well-regarded, and award-winning, he is often commissioned to produce work for radio. The women listen to the distorted recording that plays through P.’s smartphone. It is a story about many things, but one of the themes is that love can only flourish when there are boundaries. Everyone claps when it is finished. No one asks any questions.
Once that story is over, the women are led to a crypt shimmering with candles. Shadows crawl along the cold stone. An older woman named Queenie leans over to a younger one and urges her not to sit directly on the rock. “It’s bad for the kidneys,” she says mysteriously.
P. wants to share another one of his stories. He begins to read from the podium, his voice loud and grainy. His main character loves his gay community who like to party. But he also speaks of imagining a different life—a life with a child. He pictures a son, even though he’s always gotten along better with girls. His tragedy is that he will never be a dad; he believes that having a child would be the most selfish thing he could do.
Many of the women wish they hadn’t finished their wine, that their glasses aren’t so empty. They clap when it is over. P. brings a hand to his heart. There are no blankets in the crypt to stave off the cold and the women return to their beds shivering.
Some of the women have written for The New York Times. Some have published with major houses, and some have been courted by sought-after agents. P., though, has been nominated for many, many awards, and has won some too. Most nights, he sits at the head of the table, while his two friends, Maria and Lacy, serve him. And while he swigs his wine, he speaks of his time in London, “a young man’s city,” where he worked as a playwright. He doesn’t mention any Olivier awards, but he does speak of his novel and how it’s been translated into various languages.
“The more specific you are, the more universal the work. That’s why my book is read in places like Russia.”
He smiles, and his lips curl, canine-like.
Seated near him is A. She has come all the way from Canada, hopeful she will experience something indelible. She has never minded travelling alone. An ocean separates her from her young sons and husband, and she will miss them. But she’s been looking forward to this week for many months. A. has published a bit, but isn’t well known. Recently, though, she’s had a small win: one of her stories will be read on Irish radio in the coming weeks, the same broadcaster that has featured P.’s work. She thinks of telling him this, but chooses not to. She worries it might seem boastful.
Over dinner, she tells P. that she loved his book, felt he’d really captured the perspective of an adolescent boy.
P. smiles, cheeks red from the wine, and says, “I didn’t know you could still get my book in Canada.”
A. doesn’t tell him it was difficult to find, though it was. She’s just glad she was able to buy a copy in advance of her flight. She thought it would be impolite to show up not having read his work.
“The ending was pitch perfect. I thought I knew what might happen, but you still surprised me.”
P. wags his finger at A. as if she’s cracked a secret code.
“Yes. That’s exactly it. An ending should be an expected surprise.”
A. listens as he speaks, her fork and knife suspended above her plate.
“Well, you definitely delivered,” she says.
In his workshops, P. offers additional insights into his craft.
“Never underestimate the power of an opening line,” he says, index finger pointed to the ceiling.
He recalls an encounter he once had with someone esteemed who quoted the first sentence of P.’s own book. Evidence of the timeless quality of his writing. P. reminds the women that it is not enough, however, to simply write a good opening. The body of a piece must have substance and layers. One must reveal to others what may not be evident to them, that which they may not have the strength to grasp.
“In my novel, the narrator learns that his mother loves his father more than him. You wouldn’t believe how many people can relate to that.”
He doesn’t explain why he understands love as a finite resource. An asset to be divided, like a pie. Some people get more, some people less.
“Where’s your pen and notebook?” he asks A.
Startled, she leans forward and says, “I learn better just by listening.”
He sniffs the air, disbelieving.
When they break, P. says, “Go ahead and grab a coffee, reapply your lip gloss, do whatever.”
One woman raises an eyebrow, but doesn’t protest.
The nightly salons are filled with a certain frisson. This is where the women will read works in progress and listen in silence as P. critiques them. He has listed a number of rules for this exercise: only he is allowed to offer his opinion, and each reading is allocated a maximum of ten minutes.
One woman, an author of historical fiction with a devoted following, reads an excerpt from a draft of her most recent work with a shaky voice. After she’s finished, P. considers her momentarily as she stands with her text clutched between her fingers. Then he remarks that her writing shows promise, but she needs to avoid clichés like “a blanket of snow” and “a deer caught in headlights.” She nods in agreement, and there is something like relief in her eyes as if she expected far worse.
P. really likes some of the readers. One such reader is Lilliana, a sparkling blonde dedicated to fighting climate change through her advocacy work, whose piece opens with the severing of a contract with God.There is a sincerity and an openness in her that is becoming. The women laugh. Lilliana beams.
“You certainly know how to grab a listener’s attention,” P. says.
Another woman, Jane, is praised for her quiet, insightful prose. She whistles through false teeth as she speaks. Twice-divorced but now in love with her third husband, her greatest joys are her children and grandchildren. She recalls the time she bought the children ice cream on a day out even though the temperatures had plummeted. Their teeth had chattered as they enjoyed their treat, while other adults looked on disapprovingly. That week, she will make an offhand comment at breakfast to a group of white women seated at one table and a group of black women seated at another.
It’s reported she’ll say: “Oh, look at us! Isn’t this awful? Just like segregation!”
She’ll giggle behind her hand. And because what she says is so shocking, the other women will wonder if they imagined it.
“It’s always the sweet, old, white British women. They get away with it,” one witness will note.
Jane says nothing so provocative during her reading. She narrates a poetic story between two unlikely lovers. The writing is both restrained and rich.
P. is left almost speechless.
“It’s the unassuming, observant ones like you who often write the best,” he says.
Queenie steps forward. She doesn’t have anything to read but wants to tell a joke. She only drinks red wine, hates pasta, and prefers the texture of chicken, which she claims to eat every evening back home in London. She’s an aged rocker with frizzled hair and sculpted biceps. Very health-conscious. She will later attempt to compliment one of her fellow writers, Taylor: “I bet the men all loved you when you were in LA,” she’ll growl. “A black girl from London.” Taylor will sigh and say nothing.
Tonight, Queenie also speaks from the heart. Her joke ends with a bride asking her husband what a penis is on their wedding night. After he reveals his appendage to her, she says, “Oh, I get it. It’s like a prick, only smaller.” Queenie shudders with laughter. She raises her almost empty wine glass for a cheers and is met with a smattering of applause. P. claps too, but jumps in before it dies down. “Well done,” he says, though it sounds like he doesn’t mean it. He clasps his hands together, commanding everyone’s attention.
The women fall silent.
It’s A.’s turn.
She rises from her chair and stands in front, slouched, even though she’s always trying to straighten her shoulders. Her long hair covers part of her face. She hates this sort of thing but forces herself to do it, because she believes in the myth that it is somehow good for her. She reads from her short story, a sentimental tale about an artist confronting his past on a reclusive island. P. stares at his phone throughout the reading, scrolling with a meaty finger. When A. finishes, he places a hand on his chin.
“What you wrote,” he says, “is quite North American, isn’t it?”
She doesn’t understand what he means by this, but she listens to him, because he has won awards and she liked his novel.
“Stephen King,” he says, “advises writers to use adjectives sparingly. Otherwise, the writing comes across as a bit… amateurish.” He directs this at her. A burning sensation creeps from her stomach to her head. She understands now. He is not her friend.
He launches into his next attack about the narrative. He gets many things wrong because he wasn’t really listening, but that’s not the point—she is learning. She’s discovering that what he really wants is to put her in her place. She is beneath him, and he needs everyone in the room to know this.
“An artist escaping to an island… it’s just so… cliché.”
“It’s based on a true story,” A. says.
“That’s not the point,” P. says.
“I know what you’re going to say. You’re going to say that just because something actually happened doesn’t make it artful.”
His eyes sharpen. He points at her. “Yes, but I’m going to say it better than you. Just because it’s true doesn’t make it believable. You wouldn’t believe what’s happened to me, what I’ve experienced in this world as a gay man.”
P. continues on, but A. is no longer listening. She’s a bit numb, but feels enough to know that what is happening is not good, that it will not sit well with her for quite some time after it’s finished. Her thoughts are interrupted when P. looks at her with his doggish grin and says, “Make America great again!”
She responds, confused, “But I’m Canadian.”
“I know you are,” he snaps.
The critique is over. A. wants to go back to her room and throw a blanket over her head. But that would be spineless. She needs to see the evening through.
Moments later, an older woman named Effie leans over to A. and whispers, “He was very harsh.” Effie’s eyes apologize even though she’s done nothing wrong.
That evening, before everyone goes to sleep, A. approaches P., wanting to make sense of her abuse. He pulls her in close to him, so that she is pressed against his soft body, as if they were friends. He feels damp and his breath smells of stale wine. She wants to pull away.
“I know people,” he says. “My friend Emilia, for instance. She’s in Canada. You know her? Nominated for the Booker? You let me know when your book’s ready to come out, and I’ll put you in contact. She could write you a blurb.”
It’s an apology, of sorts.
She doesn’t accept. She frees herself from the award winner’s hold. Walks back to her room, takes out her computer, types what she remembers, saves it in a folder, closes her eyes, and tries to sleep.
The next day over lunch, P. does something different. He chooses not to sit at the head of the table. Instead, he sits across from A. She’s still a bit wounded, slept poorly the night before, wondering which hated person she reminds him of.
P. tries to engage her and asks about her family.
“I bet your husband is having a rough time alone with the kids,” he says with a knowing smile.
The women next to her go quiet. They wonder what she’ll say.
A. looks up from her plate and stares at P. She recalls his story, about the man who wanted a son, who imagined what it might be like to be a father.
“He misses me,” she says. “But he’s fine on his own. My sons are his best friends.”
A. speaks the truth and knows this is not the answer P. wanted to hear.
She bites into a hard piece of bread, continues to stare. He looks away, toward the windows framing dark sky at her back.
Toward the empty, lifeless corner of the room.